Skip to main content

Click here for a new page with all the participant comments for a few extra laughs.

Notes

Here you can view all the lovely things people had to say about the featured whiskeys and also view pictures that they have submitted.

Wildcard

Hands down favorite...it's not coffee flavored though...points off.

PPP

Like cherries soaked in vanilla syrup and lit on fire. Whatever it is, it's barrel-proof!

Christopher Reeves

BAND-AID

Oh this one is something. Nose has char, toasted, honey, caramel, HOLY WHAT THE nip had a quick hint of fruit and then an absolute wall of heat! Finish has sourwood after a good 30 seconds. Added water and the fruit lingers maybe pear and dash of coconut? My youngest son says my breath smells like cheesecake so. Loved it!

Hanky

This is bourbon done right. This needs to win.

Jim Brown

Smooth thick honey on the tongue but fierce and spicy on the tail end. Rye?

Zach Bennett

Fruity up front and bitter on the backend. I liked it. Felt strong.

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

A pretty good Scotch. Straight down the middle. Tastes like a partridge in a pear tree if the partridge flew away.

Hallie Knuffman

Hallie Knuffman

So...scotchy, peaty, woody, but not smoky and distracting, so I can actually catch the flavors. Not saying I loved it, but it was fun to taste.

Nate Knuffman

I'm warming up to the scotches, and this is tasty. It's floral on the nose, with some great oak flavor.

Wildcard

Smells like Scotch...tastes like Scotch...one of these days, I will find one that I like. Peaty and tastes like sawdust.

Teryn Glunz

Smells like scotch. Tastes like scotch. Getting more peat than smoke. Smooth with not too much of an after taste which I appreciate.

Quotes

Delicious scotch. More peat than smoke. I love it.

Tubs

Roasted vanilla with a hint of sour dough

Kevin Guyer

Love me some scotch, I really liked this one.

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 🪣

Peated but not overly so. English leather, some tropical fruit... Talisker? Jura?

Johan Martinez

Citrus and fruity to the nose. Definitely not a bourbon/Tennessee.

Josh Light

Saltwater on the nose with some smokiness that reminds me of Scotch. Smooth easy sipper.

Zach Bennett

Its aight. Fruity.

WeGo

Mellow scotch whisky. Not smoky or peaty.

Greg Baur

Either Scotch or a smoked whiskey.

Kimmy C

Gross

Christopher Reeves

BAND-AID

Three! It's the magic number. All my favorites: smoke, tobacco, bandaids... loved it.

Matt Roberson

not smooth enough for me

Full Body

These can be serious or sarcastic. Your call...

We serve cookies on this site to analyze traffic, remember your preferences, and optimize your experience.