Notes

Here you can view all the lovely things people had to say about the featured whiskeys and also view pictures that they have submitted.

Kim Cleary

Kimmy C

Harper says this smells like depression.

Ben Freeman

Wildcard

Diggin this one. Fruity/honey/wine nose. Honey Nut Cheerios and raisins taste. Tastes like a bourbon and Scotch mixed together. Going with "other" tonight.

Johan Martinez

Bubble gum and rubber to nose. Licorice taste Def not a bourbon. I’m thinking this may be an exotic whiskey off an island somewhere.

Nate Knuffman

Smells and tastes like sawdust mixed with buttered popcorn.

Hallie Knuffman

Would be interested to taste this next to yesterday's. They seem similar to me, but I'm still a relative Scotch newb.

Josh Light

I can't get much out of scotches, but getting peat (which i describe as saltwater) on the nose. Another light sipper that goes down easy. I just don't enjoy scotch, it seems to be a lot of the same with each bottle, but again I'm not a huge fan of scotch.

Scott Beckett

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 🪣

Stewed apples on the nose. Green apples on the palate, some cinnamon, some like dusty furniture polish. I wonder if this is Japanese…

Jim Brown

What's that smell? My first guess was cat poo, but i can't quite place it forreals. Kinda fruity / nutty? The flavor doesn't hold up though and it just kinda tastes like scotch. It's ok I guess but doesn't hold a candle to the others we've had so far.

Teryn Glunz

Pretty pleasant aroma - citrus and peat, but then I took a sip and, well, not so great. It kind of tastes like someone took a swig of scotch and then spat it back out before it got to me. So like, backwash. That's all I'm gonna say.

Derek Glunz

Quotes

I get notes of saltwater and maple syrup on the nose. The flavor is watered down and boring. To quote PPP, this whiskey is "forgettable." I keep guessing other and regretting it, but here we go again...

Josh Mitchell

Full Body

This is interesting. Not in a good way.

Christopher Reeves

BAND-AID

This one is tough for me. I tend to dislike higher proofs, but the heat here is so unbalanced? I hardly get any on the nose, but it overwhelms on the taste. Prob gonna miss in the proof. Anyway, I get fruit and nuts, cedar, varnish.

John McDowell

Worm

Nose is caramel. Nice flavor and structure. Like a dessert scotch

Zach Bennett

Two scotches in a row?

Nick Stone

More scotch. Yeah. Peat. Leather. Peanuts - maybe pecan. Sweet finish. Call if peanut brittle.

James Hatfield

Hanky

So much vanilla. This is fantastic.

Curtis Mulder

Very good. Very mellow. Caramel. Again - surprised at how much I'm enjoying these Scotches.

Allan Maule

PPP

Charming dram. Sweet and plummy, like it was aged in sherry barrels.

James Hopkins

Tubs

Cozy

Curtis Mulder

Meh.

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

Having a hard time placing this one in anything other than vanilla flavored rubbing alcohol. I don't hate it, but the first feel on the palate is more bite than is comfortable. The finish is really nice and getting some vanilla wafer vibes. It just disappears quick.

Johan Martinez

This one is hard to guess. Either very cheap or very expensive haha

Hallie Knuffman

Very nice. Lots of brown sugar/maple. But kinda fruity too? A little hot, but not too hot.

Wil Saleeby

A little hot on the nose. Nice flavor and finish. Very nice ($$$) but maybe a bit "vanilla?

Prev Next