Hall of Fame
2025
Contributor: Jonathan (Cory) Kraftchick
Best Whiskeys
1st - Blue Run Emerald II Rye (6.74)
2nd - Russell's Reserve Private Barrel Selection (6.70)
3rd - Henry McKenna Single Barrel (6.69)
Worst Whiskeys
Oban 14 Year Old (5.97)
Jim Beam Kentucky Straight Bourbon (5.98)
Auchentoshan Three Wood (6.01)
2024
Contributor: Hanky (James Hatfield)
Best Whiskeys
1st - Mystic Broken Oak (7.12)
2nd - Still Austin Cask Strength (6.86)
3rd - Eagle Rare 10 Year (6.72)
Worst Whiskeys
Mortlach 12 Year Old "The Wee Witchie" (5.70)
Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye "Distiller's Edition" (5.94)
Laws Whiskey House Four Grain Straight Bourbon - Cask Strength (6.13)
2023
Contributor: Quotes (Derek G)
Best Whiskeys
1st - Old Ezra 7-Year Straight Rye (7.11)
2nd - Heart of Mystic Bottled in Bond (6.83)
3rd - Heaven Hill Bottled in Bond (6.56)
Worst Whiskeys
Talisker Storm (4.60)
White Oak Akashi Blended Whisky (5.02)
Stauning Kaos Triple-Malted Whisky (5.07)
2022
Contributor: Quotes (Derek G)
Best Whiskeys
1st - Belle Meade Reserve Bourbon (7.00)
2nd - Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel (6.95)
3rd - Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style (6.81)
Worst Whiskeys
Jameson Cold Brew (4.60)
Macallan Double Cask 12 Year (5.30)
Craigellachie 13 Year (5.39)
2021
Contributor: Precious (Matt Eagle)
Best Whiskeys
1st - Larceny Barrel Proof (7.70)
2nd - Woodford Reserve Batch Proof 2018 (7.29)
3rd - New Riff Single Barrel Rye (6.95)
Worst Whiskeys
Charbay R5 Hop Flavored Whiskey (4.33)
Laphroaig 10 Year Old Sherry Oak Finish (4.42)
Fireball Cinnamon Whiskey (4.69)
2020
Contributor: Quotes (Derek G)
Best Whiskeys
1st - Colonel E.H. Taylor Small Batch (7.28)
2nd - George Dickel 11 Year Bottled in Bond (7.10)
3rd - Infinity Bottle (7.10)
Worst Whiskeys
Speyburn Bradan Orach Single Malt (5.21)
Writer's Tears Pot Still (5.68)
Glenlivet Founder's Reserve (5.81)
2019
Contributor: Umbro (Justin Carroll)
Best Whiskeys
1st - Elijah Craig Barrel Proof (7.70)
2nd - Stagg Jr. (7.60)
3rd - Belle Meade Bourbon Sherry Cask Finish (7.43)
Worst Whiskeys
Kilchoman Vintage 2009 (4.69)
Jameson Caskmates (5.44)
Amrut Fusion (5.46)
2018
Contributor: Hef (Jonathan/Cory)
Best Whiskeys
1st - Four Roses Single Barrel Private Selection OBSQ (7.32)
2nd - Maker's Mark Private Select (7.09)
3rd - Belle Meade Bourbon Sherry Cask Finish (7.00)
Worst Whiskeys
Ardbeg An Oa (5.19)
Lagavulin 16 Year (5.31)
Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban Port Cask Finish 12 Year (5.39)
2017
Contributor: Quotes (Derek Glunz)
Best Whiskeys
1st - Booker's 2017-03 Front Porch Batch (7.20)
2nd - Makers 46 (6.82)
3rd - Hibiki Harmony (6.73)
Worst Whiskeys
Jameson Caskmates (5.25)
Palmetto Whiskey (5.58)
Woodford Reserve (5.58)