Skip to main content

REMINDER: Day 1 is always last year's winning whiskey (MYSTIC BROKEN OAK, PROOF 100).

Notes

Here you can view all the lovely things people had to say about the featured whiskeys and also view pictures that they have submitted.

Quotes

Tastes really good, a tad bit too sweet, definite notes of melon

Erin Kraftchick

Mrs Hef

Wheeew! That's some strong stuff. Different kind of smell, kinda like a scotch. Tastes strong and a little like a smokey bourbon. Seems like a good drink for the high rollers cigar smokers. It's unique for sure. Like a bourbon aged in a smoked barrel. Ha.

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

Loving this. It's like a cigar made beautiful love to a peppermint and they created this bottle of joy that will inextricably link them for eternity.

Worm

Tastes like bourbon mixed with toothpaste. Seriously.

Full Body

I asked my wife what the finish was, and she said, Poison."\nHowever, I really enjoyed this. Still can't place that flavor, though."

Zach Lose

Nosey

Christian Sito

Good hearty bourbon. Yum

Jena Singleton

This is lovely 😊

Hanky

Smells like musty wood. Tastes like sweet sugary musty wood. This is complex and has a long finish. It’s really delicious. 7/10

Jack Murphy

This one is great.

Vern McClendon

Dill Pickle on the nose, but man this one is tasty. Love the looooooooong finish

Christian Sito

Not a big fan

Shaft

Yeah, yeah click-clack

Shaft

Pairs well with 🍣

Aaron Carter

Not bad for Scotch

Full Body

No thank you.

Jack Murphy

I'm pretty sure this is Japanese. Nikka or Hibiki? I'd go with Nikka.

Worm

Not as scotchy as the others- maybe not scotch? Japanese? Still quite good IMO

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

If this is scotch, am I starting to like scotch? If this is Japanese, am I starting to like Japanese?

Erin Kraftchick

Mrs Hef

Not a fan

Dan Sembler

Second night in a row I think this is a scotch. And it's probably the 2nd night in a row I'll be wrong.

Nate Knuffman

Solid scotch.

PPP

Has the fiery finish of Glenlivet Nadurra.

Hanky

Super light color and soft floral smell. Has a green apple and floral flavor. 5/10

We serve cookies on this site to analyze traffic, remember your preferences, and optimize your experience.