Skip to main content

REMINDER: Day 1 is always last year's winning whiskey (MYSTIC BROKEN OAK, PROOF 100).

Notes

Here you can view all the lovely things people had to say about the featured whiskeys and also view pictures that they have submitted.

Kim Roberson

Hot smell, vanilla/clove taste. Festive!

Michael Pelletier

Michael Pelletier

Great aroma and a nice finish considering the high proof. Thinking back to day 1

Erin Kraftchick

Mrs Hef

Chocolatey, sweet and smooth.

Dan Sembler

Dark in color. Did someone put motor oil in my bottle? Hot. But not harsh. Has to be a bourbon. And a barrel strength of something?

Adam Daland

Oily and bitter. Not a fan.

Ronnie Eubanks

GET IN MY BELLY!!! Oh this is a favorite for sure.

Christian Sito

Sweet and spicy. Good stuff

Aaron Carter

I like this one! Reminds me of Stagg Jr.

Michael Pelletier

Michael Pelletier

Nice easy drinker.

Erin Kraftchick

Mrs Hef

tastes like... bourbon. Really good bourbon.

Christian Sito

This is delicious. Very much enjoyed it.

Christian Sito

Didn’t cheat. This was an easy pick based on color and flavor.

Steve Kraftchick

Steve Kraftchick

Nice amber color, some smoke, has the burn of a scotch on the back of the throat

Adam Daland

Smells great. Some subtle cherry notes.

Dan Sembler

Has to be a scotch. Smokey scotch. Laphroig?

Kim Roberson

Smooth and easy to drink

Kim Roberson

Nice and smokey~

smokey loved it

Curtis Mulder

Oooh ... this is good. Gotta be bourbon. So warm in my belly on this snow day!!

Aaron Carter

NO!

Michael Pelletier

Michael Pelletier

Mmm. Nice and smoky.

Adam Daland

Kindof peanutty smell. Nice and peaty taste. I like it!

Erin Kraftchick

Mrs Hef

Tastes like I just went to the dentist. Yuck.

Zach Lose

This has to be a scotch. And I’m noticing that while I typically prefer bourbons over most other types, the nose on the scotch’s is incredible compared to the others.

We serve cookies on this site to analyze traffic, remember your preferences, and optimize your experience.