Skip to main content

REMINDER: Day 1 is always last year's winning whiskey (MYSTIC BROKEN OAK, PROOF 100).

Notes

Here you can view all the lovely things people had to say about the featured whiskeys and also view pictures that they have submitted.

Zach Bennett

Another enjoyable one here. Getting some cherry in there. I’d drink that again

Full Body

Really good Scotch. Which means it's not a Scotch, but something else.

Zach Lose

I love scotch. Scotchy scotch scotch. Here it goes down. Down into my belly.

Precious

Wow, interesting nose, high proof, good flavor. Enjoyable!

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 🪣

Think I got spoiled on this one, but I hope I'd get at least the style without help. It's definitely Islay scotch, on the subtle side with the smoke by Islay standards.

Precious

Nah dog. Either be a scotch or don’t. Middle ground impostors need not apply.

Brandon Eagle

This this is a campfire with a good burn. I like it. It’s a lot… could probably only slang one of these a night. Guessing high proof to go with the burn..?

PPP

Smoky and delicious. Guessing by the odd finish this is not a scotch

Aaron Carter

Excellent, not normally the type of whiskey I would seek out but great!

Greg Baur

This shit is trying to ruin my Xmas. Smells like a rubber fire. Same category as Laphraoig. Yuck

Hallie Knuffman

Hallie Knuffman

This was manageable. Dare I say, a little sweet and spicy.

Josh Light

Melon & dark fruit on the nose. Taste cocoa and dark fruit on palate. Almost seems like port barrel finish.

Hallie Knuffman

Hallie Knuffman

Soooo nice!! Christmas in a bottle. In the top 3 for me for this year.

Erin Kraftchick

Mrs Hef

Ughhhh

Hallie Knuffman

Hallie Knuffman

Tobacco. Dirt. I keep getting maple syrup too.

Nate Knuffman

It's like drinking a cigar coated in soil. Has to be a scotch, right?

Quotes

Smokey, peaty scotch. Crazy how dark & red this is in the glass. It’s really smooth, but not my favorite.

Teryn Glunz

Smoky and syrupy. Maybe a bit of dark fruit. For a scotch I don’t hate it, but yeah, don’t really like it either.

Worm

More scotch like things? Scotch or a scotch-like product? I’m guessing actual scotch.

Curtis Mulder

Scotch Scotch Scotch. Drinkin' a campfire.

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

I had to let this one sit out for a bit and it got better when every sip. Getting some apples all the way throughout.

Wildcard

Yup...Scotch. Lightweight, sweet, smoke. I have learned im not a huge Scotch fan, but this one isn't bad at all.

Shaft

Bourbon is back, baby!

Vern McClendon

first tasting was blah. second tasting was holy cow!

We serve cookies on this site to analyze traffic, remember your preferences, and optimize your experience.