Skip to main content

Click here for a new page with all the participant comments for a few extra laughs.

Notes

Here you can view all the lovely things people had to say about the featured whiskeys and also view pictures that they have submitted.

Jack Murphy

Notes of caramel and spice

Michael Pelletier

Michael Pelletier

Not bad. Some toffee, maybe vanilla, interesting.

Dan Sembler

Woah. This is interesting. Can’t be a bourboun My guess is a scotch or some Japanese? I don’t think I’ve had this before.

Zach Lose

It smelled like wine at first which makes me think its back to back Other's... but based on my accuracy so far it's probably a Rye.

Michael Pelletier

Michael Pelletier

Interesting flavors in this. Very soft, mellow,

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

apples and cinnamon. not terrible!

Dan Sembler

Very light and easy to drink. This has to be a scotch or japanese whiskey, right?

Zach Lose

man that first sniff... almost gave the whole pour to the raisin right off the bat. Tasted ok actually, but the nose on it is not for me

Michael Pelletier

Michael Pelletier

Has an odd metallic aftertaste. Ok otherwise.

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

Not horrible, and maybe even good?

Dan Sembler

I am getting something really funky in this one...and not in a good way. Could be the Mediterranean dinner i just finished. I think it's a bourbon, but I'm getting a strange metallic aftertaste...

Michael Pelletier

Michael Pelletier

Nice smoke, but not overpowering.

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

Not bourbon. Definitely scotch. And I don't hate it.

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

Not sure what this is. Kind of tastes like bourbon, but kind of doesn't. I'm really loving it though.

Michael Pelletier

Michael Pelletier

Delicious.

Dan Sembler

Very unique. Dried fruits, apricots? Hey dark in color. The only thing I’ve had even close to resembling this was Taiwanese whiskey (Kavalan). Going to give this a 7, perhaps out of uniqueness alone.

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

Whoa. Coming in hot. Tastes big and expensive.

Michael Pelletier

Michael Pelletier

Really smooth and round mouthfeel and then it kicks your throat with boot spurs. Wow.

Jack Murphy

Spicy, caramel, and smoky. Reminds me of High West Whiskey.

Michael Pelletier

Michael Pelletier

Starting off the back half well. This is nice especially considering it's high proof.

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

Apples! Or not. Whatever. Tastes expensive though.

Jack Murphy

Very mellow. Slight clove taste.

Michael Pelletier

Michael Pelletier

Not my favorite. Some bready and almond notes in the aroma.

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

Good, but a bit more watery than some of the others we've had recently.

We serve cookies on this site to analyze traffic, remember your preferences, and optimize your experience.