Notes

Here you can view all the lovely things people had to say about the featured whiskeys and also view pictures that they have submitted.

View All High Rollers Morganton Cigar Club Cherry Bekaert and Alum The Women of Whiskey CPAs
2025 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017
Screenshot_20231122_185334_Photos.jpg
Josh Mitchell
Full Body
My palate for non-Highland Scotch is improving, so I'm tolerating this more than I would have in previous years. That said, I'm still not enjoying this as much as other scotches.
Mitch Mitchell
WeGo
Loved it.
FullSizeRender.jpeg
James Hatfield
Hanky
I knew this one from the smell. I love it.
IMG_3154.jpeg
James Hopkins
Tubs
Smokey Smokey Smokey—I enjoyed this.
Mitch Mitchell
WeGo
Islay scotch, Smokey
IMG_5642_Original.jpeg
Derek Glunz
Quotes
Lots of smoke, comes off as a scotch from the nose all the way through. Buttery, silky texture to it. Not my favorite on flavor, but still enjoyable.
IMG_6810.jpeg
John McDowell
Worm
The drugs I give to knock people unconscious and paralyze them smell better than this. Like licking a bandaid from the 1960s.
PXL_20230322_151118992.jpg
Jonathan Cory Kraftchick
Hef
This one tastes like medicine to me and I feel like I'm getting healthier with every sip.
AllanMaule_Slack_Size_Pic.png
Allan Maule
PPP
Lots of spicy rye in this mash. Candied cherries on the nose, vanilla taste, caramel finish. Not bad at all.
FullSizeRender.jpeg
James Hatfield
Hanky
I think I knew this one from the smell. It’s absolutely fantastic. Sweet smoke.
Screenshot_20230527_081921_Photos.jpg
Mark Peters
Shaft
Definitely putting this one on the list......of things to avoid.
Screenshot_20230527_081921_Photos.jpg
Mark Peters
Shaft
Alas! Spicy lemongrass
Screenshot_20231122_185334_Photos.jpg
Josh Mitchell
Full Body
I like this ok. It doesn't tested like Bourbon. Maybe a Rye? Edit: Gets worse the more I drink it. Edit #2: Don't think it's Rye now. Just going with Other.
IMG_5831.jpeg
Matt Eagle
Precious
Oh baby, yes! My mouth hasn’t been tingled like this since that one time in college. Praise hands.
IMG_6810.jpeg
John McDowell
Worm
So close to being amazing, but there’s some hint of iodine/scotch note on the end- would prefer a sweeter finish. Love the higher proof.
IMG_5642_Original.jpeg
Derek Glunz
Quotes
The smell is familiar, the taste is complex and enthralling. I get hints of spice and plum. The whiskey has a strong punch behind it, with a strong alcohol content. Some type of barrel proof, maybe Bookers.
Justin Carroll
Umbro (Justin Carroll)
Delicious
Mitch Mitchell
WeGo
Lowlands scotch, maybe Auchentoshan
Ben Freeman
Wildcard
This is the shit. Period. High proof, easy to drink. Caramel and vanilla nose. Oak taste, tastes like Werthers
Ben Freeman
Wildcard
This is garbage...super smoke flavor, like eating a campfire. Smells like a type of medicine I have had before. This is ANGRY....
IMG_3154.jpeg
James Hopkins
Tubs
Burnt caramel—charcoal and sour after taste. Very Strong. Good Stuff
Ben Freeman
Wildcard
nose is spicy and grainy. Taste is straight-up heat, high alcohol content. Reminds me of when i first had hard liquor and it burned fucking everywhere. Realizing I am a sweeter bourbon whore ...oh, and I cant get the taste of the dumpster on fire number 2 out of my mouth.
PXL_20230322_151118992.jpg
Jonathan Cory Kraftchick
Hef
Happy to be back on the bourbon train with a nice high proof.
AllanMaule_Slack_Size_Pic.png
Allan Maule
PPP
Has the lightness and smooth sweetness of an Irish spirit. Tastes of lemon candy and cream. Weak finish but not bad for a Saturday afternoon.
Prev
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63
Next