Skip to main content

Click here for a new page with all the participant comments for a few extra laughs.

Notes

Here you can view all the lovely things people had to say about the featured whiskeys and also view pictures that they have submitted.

Wildcard

This is insanely good. It smells exactly like chocolate covered cherries and amaretto. It takes a second for the heat to drop, but after giving it some air, it shines.

Tubs

Strong in the wrong way. Decent.

Quotes

Sweet delicious bourbon done really well. This is one of my favorite bourbons and I was so happy to see it get the recognition it deserves last year. It’s as good as I remember.

Shaft

It's just so good.

Worm

It tastes like burning…in a good way. Excited to enjoy this experience with my friends. Thanks Cory

Full Body

It's so smooth. A wonderful balance of sweet & spice.

Hanky

Yum

Precious

Hard to argue with last year’s winner. I always enjoy the burn of higher proof.

PPP

How could I ever have described this dram as "forgettable?" An explosion of caramelly berry baked in a pie that well-deserved its crown last year. Happy Advent to All!

PPP

Did someone distill this with a rubber dildo? What is this weirdness?

PPP

The nose promised a sweet appley dessert, only to have the taste betray me with coarse leathery notes. This is like when someone makes you a cake but uses only whole wheat flour. Stop trying to fix me, you don't know my life.

PPP

Honeyed and floral scents draw you in, only to disappear into a shallow palate of forgettable meh. A great sound and fury, signifying scotch.

PPP

Spicy and strong. My mouth is still burning, but in a "How much more can I stand?" way and not "I might need Poison Control" way.

PPP

Forgettable.

PPP

Tastes like the potent sherry sweetness of Glenlivet Nadurra. Amazing!

PPP

Charming dram. Sweet and plummy, like it was aged in sherry barrels.

PPP

Like cherries soaked in vanilla syrup and lit on fire. Whatever it is, it's barrel-proof!

PPP

Scotchy, but with a bit more sweetness and levity. Charming but the weak finish keeps it from standing out.

PPP

Nicely rounded and sweet. Excellent dram.

PPP

Like an orange cream pie. Delicious and sweet.

PPP

Tastes like a crisp and smoky young Ardbeg. Looking forward to reading angry comments on this one.

PPP

My mouth is on fire with joy. Tastes like the potent sherry sweetness of Glenlivet Nadurra. Amazing!

PPP

Sweet and dessert like. Nice dram.

PPP

My wife stepped in to taste this, cringed, and said, "Ugh this has a finish of soap!"

We serve cookies on this site to analyze traffic, remember your preferences, and optimize your experience.